Speculation: Glass Trackpad

October 12, 2008

I want to make this clear from the start: THIS IS SPECULATION. This is not something I heard from a source: this is shear speculation. That being said, if you think you can bear to read the whole article without telling me how stupid I am for believing this as fact, click the read link.

Here’s my thinking. 9 to 5 Mac, the most reliable source around, has heard word there will be a glass trackpad on the new laptops. Mac Soda can confirm this is true. Some have asked the question, “What’s the point of a glass trackpad if there’s no screen?” There are two answers to this question.

1. It is simply because it would enable for more advanced gestures that the current trackpads can’t handle.

2. It doesn’t make sense. That’s why there will be a screen.

Assuming #2 is the correct answer, one might ask the question, “What’s the point of a screen on the trackpad?” I think I know the answer.

Apple has not made it a secret that they want to bring multi-touch, in its entirety, to the Mac. Steve Jobs even said it himself, in an interview with the New York Times. The question is: how? They could take the approach that other manufacturers seem to be taking, and that is slapping a multi-touch display on a normal screen with normal software. However, this approach seems destined to fail, as multi-touch has no advantage over a mouse when using software optimized for the mouse. In fact, it is a disadvantage to use multi-touch, as your hands will get tired quickly, and after an hour of being at your computer, touching the screen non-stop, the novelty will fade, and you’ll shortly be searching your closest for a mouse. That is why Apple isn’t taking this approach.

The approach Apple has decided to take is a long, gradual transition: so smooth, the consumer will barely even know it happened. It is a three step process: the introduction, the tutorial, and the implementation.

They started extremely slow with multi-touch enabled trackpads found on the MBA and MBP today, that allow you to do very basic things, such as pinching to zoom, and using two fingers to scroll and pan. While they took a little adjusting at first, after a little time they became second nature. This was the introduction to multi-touch: we were given a little taste of how multi-touch can help improve our computing.

Some of Apple's Patented Gestures...

The second step is the step I think we will see Tuesday, and that is multi-touch on a small glass screen, taking the place of the trackpad. Apple has applied for a ton of patents regarding advanced multi-touch gestures, which Macrumors covered here (see picture). These will finally show their face in OS X. The biggest challenge Apple faces is getting people to learn the gestures, and that’s why the screen is there. Apple will be able to show you where to place your fingers on the trackpad represented by little dots, and then, once you’re touching them, they will change, showing you where to move your fingers. It will be the perfect way to teach you a huge amount of gestures, as you can visually see exactly what to do with your fingers. It will be hard at first, but at the end of the tutorial, this large number of advanced gestures will start to become second nature.

The final step is the step Apple is working towards: direct manipulation of objects and menus, directly on the main screen. By this time we will know the gestures, how they work, and what their purpose is. We won’t have to figure it all out at once: we’ll have already been. We will all be able to implement the knowledge we have acquired over the past few years, and we can then reap the benefits a multi-touch display can offer.

So that’s my thought process: perhaps we’ll see a multi-touch trackpad, made of glass, with a screen, showing you how to perform all of these advanced multi-touch gestures.

But remember: this is all just speculation… 😉

28 Responses to “Speculation: Glass Trackpad”

  1. vonspace said

    that would be great…….really really great I hope so…

  2. Robert Goulet said

    How can you say MacSoda can confirm this if this is all speculation? That’s just stupid…

    There won’t be glass trackpads. End of story. Your idea of showing you where to move your fingers next could easily be done in an on screen pop up window of some sort. There’s no point in spending that much money on a trackpad to show you where to move your fingers when you could do it in some kind of dialogue box on the screen. Apple is looking to lower prices and become more competitive. Not waste money on useless features that will jack up the price.

    On the other hand, you could say that there won’t be a screen underneath it. Ok then, what will be underneath it? Aluminum? A piece of black plastic? A glass trackpad would look plain stupid. Apple is all about aesthetics. A glass trackpad with nothing under it would be an HP or Dell move. If you want your glass trackpad, look to them to do it, because it’ll be ugly as sin.

  3. alex mtz said

    you’re so stupid for believing these facts… NOT!!

    HAHA

    it’ll be a GIANT leap!! Perhaps another apple invention to revolutionize the world?(aka. Mouse, iPhone)

    Let’s all hope the battery lasts more than 3 hours despite the 2 screens, the bluray and everything else.

  4. str1f3 said

    i’m really hoping you’re right.

  5. @ Robert Goulet

    I am astonished you can read this and think that we confirmed it. You obviously missed the whole part about it being speculation…

  6. Robert Goulet said

    @ Michael Contaxis
    ” 9 to 5 Mac, the most reliable source around, has heard word there will be a glass trackpad on the new laptops. Mac Soda can confirm this is true.”

    I’m astonished that you can’t comprehend what I said.

    “How can you say MacSoda can confirm this if this is all speculation? That’s just stupid…” You’re the one who said it was all true after you said it was speculation. That’s why I said it’s stupid. That’s why I gave my two cents on why there won’t be glass trackpads. Because you said it was speculation, which it obviously is.

  7. I can confirm the glass trackpad. I can’t confirm the screen, or anything I posted besides that.

  8. Joris (Netherlands) said

    @Mike Contaxis
    Keep up the good work, I’ve added your site a couple of days ago to my Apple-tab in safari and opening it together with all the other apple rumour sites (about 4 times a day around the introduction).
    Love to hear about all the speculation, it’s like food for my imagination (and in sometimes you can even confince me about how realistic some speculations can be). So don’t stop writing because of some idiots that don’t see what effort you put in this site and flame on every post.

    @Robert Goulet
    Why flame on this post, if it is true, it would be great, if not…. you’re not going to die because of it.

  9. Jay said

    This site is awesome. I agree with Joris, though. Please do not get discouraged or anything by all the idiots who flamed your last few posts. This post, in particular, was very thoughtful, and I won’t be surprised if it actually true!

    Again, thanks for posting.

  10. jeff said

    The idea of the glass trackpad including a screen is certainly interesting, and a tutorial would be a very practical application for it. However, to justify the component cost of the screen, there would have to be a long-term value to it (i.e. application shortcuts, the option for extra “click” buttons). They’re not going to add the cost of an LCD just for a tutorial.

    I also think that if Apple is going to bring multitouch to MacBooks, we can expect them to bring it to desktop Macs by Macworld at the latest, perhaps with a touch surface mouse or a keyboard with a similar (but larger) glass trackpad. First this would unify the entire Mac experience. Second, it would allow Apple to capitalize on its lead on competitors.

    I also want to echo the sentiments of those who enjoy your site. Keep up the good work.

  11. josé ps said

    have you seen this?

    http://olo-computer.com/

  12. ronl said

    I was thinking maybe it’s purely for environmental purposes, since glass is ‘elegant but highly recycleable’. But I think it’ll be nice to have a screen to show gestures on the trackpad, or like the mockups I’ve seen: having the dock on the trackpad so as to reduce the desktop clutter.

  13. Mechno said

    Your posts are a real pleasure, Mike. It makes no sense at all to me why some people feel like they have to attack you. Perhaps it’s just insecurity or a lack of maturity.

    While I like your speculation about the possibility of the screen being a tool for tutorials, I don’t see that as the primary motivation.

    Possible reasons for a glass trackpad without a screen:
    glass is not always a pane. The glass trackpad may consist of glass fibers embedded in some substrate. This could offer higher resolution or other enhanced features.

    Possible reason for a glass trackpad with a screen:
    While gestures are good for navigation, the screen could provide a surface for manipulation. Manipulating images, video, and audio by directly touching the object has it’s charm. This is the selling point of tablets.

    What I’d like to see but won’t:
    A dock for a touch to act as the trackpad. Better than a glass trackpad with a screen is one that you can take out and use to transport your digital media.

    I applaud your ability to not let the venom get to you too much. Thanks for the info!

  14. Roman said

    I’m hoping you’re right. But it doesn’t look like a screen on the leaked case pics:

  15. @ Roman

    That’s photoshopped in. The actual photo doesn’t show the screen or the trackpad.

  16. Douwe (Netherlands) said

    @Roman and Mike;

    Exactly. This are the real pics:

    MB: http://forum.onemorething.nl/album_pic.php?pic_id=22357
    MBP: http://forum.onemorething.nl/album_pic.php?pic_id=22352

    @Rumor;
    I’d love multitouch 🙂 Nice story, nice speculation.

  17. Lee Hericks said

    Interesting speculations. I think they just scratch the surface of what Apple could/would/will do if they choose to put a glass trackpad on the new MacBooks and MacBook Pros.

    One interesting point is that the MacBook Air uses the same multi-touch processing chip found in the iPhone and iPod Touch. Apple has indeed been gradually introducing us to multi-touch on the Mac, and it is my personal belief that Steve Jobs is not interested in users smudging their fingers all over the main display. There are a plethora of reasons why touch on a notebook (sans pen) is impractical. However, with the Air, Apple has proven that the trackpad can serve as an advanced form of input. The gestures are natural and intuitive.

    When Snow Leopard (Mac OSX 10.6) was first announced, it was said that a full gesture API would be coming that allowed developers to use multi-touch in their applications. THIS IS AN IMPORTANT STATEMENT. iPhone developers are not limited by Apple-implemented gestures when developing their applications. Wait, that means Apple already has a gesture API that just needs to be repackaged for the Mac: Cocoa Touch. It’s not hard to believe that Apple may have this ready to roll with 10.5.6, which will probably roll out along-side the laptop refresh. But it is hard to believe that Apple would move to a glass trackpad, build a great multi-touch API into OSX for Mac, and severely limit its usefulness.

    Seriously, if we don’t see it yet, it’s coming at some point. Applications could use the secondary screen to show notifications, present options, and implement multi-touch interfaces just like the wildly popular Nintendo DS. Kids will be finger painting with their trackpad. Pros can carry the capacitive pen for iPhone and do touchups in photoshop through their trackpad. Students can practice writing kanji (Chinese characters used in the Japanese language) right on the trackpad, even tracing the kanji presented on the trackpad. Tired of working or studying? How about playing with “Koi Pond” (Popular iPhone application) on your trackpad? Hell, how about have swimming koi on your trackpad as a background animation? Need to balance your checkbook? Laptops don’t have a numeric pad. No need. Fire up the calculator on your trackpad and number crunch in a much more natural manner. Apple can make multi-touch on the trackpad indispensable.

    I have no connections to Apple. I have no cool, secret informants. But I can see a great vision for the advancement of Mac OSX and mobile computing (One I certainly hope Steve Jobs sees). And the awesome thing is that Apple already has all the technology out on the market: the iPhone touch screen and Cocoa Touch API.

  18. Jeff said

    @ Lee

    “But I can see a great vision for the advancement of Mac OSX and mobile computing.”

    Not just mobile computing. We have seen patents for trackpad/keyboard combinations and mice with full touch surfaces. If they do take touch to the next level in laptops tomorrow, I think it’s pretty safe to assume they will bring these capabilities to desktop Macs at or before MacWorld.

  19. Lee Hericks said

    Good point. I will upgrade my standard chiclet iMac keyboard if they do so.

    Looking forward to the media event!

  20. lrecker said

    Why are we thinking so small? Why not replace the area where a the keyboard and trackpad would be with a glass multi-touch input device? It can be a virtual (multi-language) keyboard when necessary, and Wacom-like input device for other applications. I’d love that, but I’d have a huge learning curve.

    Lance

  21. Craig said

    You shear a sheep.
    Speculation is sheer.

    There is something else that comes from sheep and just about all animals, including bulls, that also starts with sh- and comes to mind as I read this stuff.

  22. David Arquette said

    Woah woah Craig. If you’re going to be mean-spirited, at least make it funny!

  23. Lee Hericks said

    @Lance:

    At this time, powering two large displays would lead to very short battery life for mobile computers. I’m also not sure that a full touch-based keyboard would be beneficial for laptops. The benefit of a keyboard is the tactile response so that you can throw down your hands and start typing. The iPhone is a completely different beast in that writing is not it’s main function. But a laptop lacking any physical keyboard may be extremely inefficient and frustrating to use without looking down to place your fingers each time.

  24. lrecker said

    @ Lee Hericks

    Stop shattering my dreams of a Star Trek like interface! 🙂 Good points.

    Lance

  25. Poopsmith McCololing said

    You’re all a bunch of DING-DONGS! Apple has released a machine with a glass trackpad! Loolz!

  26. @ Poopsmith

    1. Don’t swear on Mac Soda. I will edit your comment.

    2. Read when this post was created (HINT: BEFORE THE GLASS TRACKPADS). It appears you’re the “DING-DONG” here. Loolz!

  27. We are looking forward to more.

Leave a comment